The Case(y) for e-MTBs

By Casey (get it?) Zilinek, SB Bike apparel buyer
  

 

Are e-mountain bikes worth it? Are they cheating? Are they "too much"? At Sports Basement we're pretty happy to embrace new technology (comes with the territory here in the Bay Area), so when one of our staffers recently started debating whether to buy one for himself, a whole lotta people immediately swiveled their chairs around to debate the merits of the e-MTB. I've got an embarrassing number of bikes in my garage at home, so , well, I have stronger opinions than most. One of the other people in the office told me to start writing all this stuff down, so here we are, and I'm sharing my rather strong opinions with the world.
 

Are e-mountain bikes "too much"?

No way! Having ridden other e mountain bikes, the Transition Repeater instantly feels more like my regular bike than an e-bike. The Shimano motor is very smooth and pedaling feels completely natural. You wouldn't really know this was electric.
 

Are they cheating?

Okay, real talk. As a lifelong mountain biker I love going downhill. The Repeater helps me get more downhill laps at my local riding spots in half the time as a regular bike. Not only that, the repetition has made me a better mountain biker all around! It doesn't hurt that its just so much fun, too.
 

Are e-MTBs worth it?

As a father of young children, having the repeater allows me to get out on a ride and do more with the time I have. I can go out for an hour and ride twice as far and still be back in time for Ruby's dance class. And while I'm on the trail, the repeater makes exploring new riding areas much easier. Going down an unknown trail isn't quite so consequential, because climbing back up to the top doesn't take as long. I've been able to explore and familiarize myself with nearly every trial (and nontrial) at my local riding spot and beyond.

So yeah, it's worth it, it's not cheating at all, it's just making you better at something that's awesome. Who could turn that down? Just buy the bike, Adrian. Jeez.

 

15 comments

  • Larry says...

    Rufus Gondardi tells it like it is……………
    I volunteer at the Laguna Canyon foundation and the abuse on trails is evident. Not content to access existing trails, ebikes have given novice riders the ability to accelerate up hill to poach and create illegal downhill runs potentially jeopardizing future access. The folks I ride with go by the motto of earning those downhill turns and protecting the environment.
    Sports Basement and others in the e mtn bike business should be pushing environmental education as much as they want to sell the bikes.

    On October 09, 2024
  • Rufus Gondardi says...

    Seems most people put their own momentary thrills and adventure far above ANY consideration about the detrimental impacts to habitats and other species. I generally think that anything that gets people out into nature is a good thing, but these gizmos are proliferating wildly — and nature is facing yet more erosion and other forms of disturbance (spreading invasive species, stressing wild creatures who tend to be living at the edge already…). People who grouse that they have no choice but to use trails illegally because there aren’t enough legal ones seem to think that they know better than the resource managers. They don’t. I love adrenaline-driven activities out in nature, and I’m grateful that there are many ways to play that don’t cause appreciable harm. E-mountain biking is, on the whole, not one of them. And if you say you don’t harm single track, because you’re a skilled rider, and you say you’re a courteous rider to all you encounter, and you claim to love nature, you still have no viable argument that these bikes are acceptable because sadly, you are in the minority.

    On October 02, 2024
  • Gunther Schmidt says...

    I feel like e-bikes have leveled the playing field so we can have truly equality on the trails. We’re finally able to compete with those of the higher melatonin levels that have all the strength and stamina to run all day. If we’re all about equity, finally the common guy can ride with the athletically gifted.

    On August 21, 2024
  • Keith says...

    For commuting, grocery shopping or casual riding with family, no problem. Physical challenges of a temporary or permanent nature? E-bikes are a good choice. My experience is that ebike riders don’t know or appear to care about bicycle courtesy and safety. They blast by on walking/multi-use trails without calling out, ride sidewalks at high speeds and often can be seen looking at their phones while riding. I have seen them get stuck on more technical sections of local trails – the e-bike got them to a place they should not have been! One recent e-bike rider collided with the curb and crashed on a busy local street. He may have looking at his phone. I stopped to assist. He momentarily was not moving – just groaning. There was blood running down his leg. I called 911. When he recovered full consciousness and I was still on the phone with the 911 operator he yelled loud enough for the 911 operator to hear that he did not want an ambulance. Is there more to say? Yes! E-bikes are not going away because I don’t like them. The dialogue continues.

    On August 16, 2024
  • Brian says...

    I think e bikes are very fun. But also agree w/ other comments… inexperienced people should get better skills prior to going so fast. They should know rules of the road, how to control their bike and just courtesy. I really dislike when people riding fast don’t slow for children or people walking, etc. Too often the ebiker seems entitled… hopefully, this will change w/ better awareness! It’s great to see more people biking!

    On September 05, 2023

Leave a comment